Showing posts with label political. Show all posts
Showing posts with label political. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Watery Motivation: Patriotism in Space

Imagine a large park with a huge stage with a lone podium. The grass can not be seen because of the numbers of people crowding trying to hear to politician's words. News cameras from every network focus on the stage. As you approach the scene, the words become clear.


"Thus, I declare that the great nation of the United States of America with have its own Moon and Mars base in the next 20 years. They will be named Base Eagle and Base Freedom, respectively. Through these two bases we will harness the resources of other planets and gain a competitive edge for the future!"


The crowd then erupts into a chant of "USA!, USA!, USA!".


Luckily, this is fiction. The world is moving away from continuing colonialism in space and instead they are working with each other to further mankind. This is great progress for us, but it brings the special challenge of Watery Motivation.


The term was first introduced to me in a writing class were we read Martha C. Nussbaum's Compassion & Terror. Her work attempts to expose the difficulties of international action on the downsides of globalism and it attempts to prove why nations can work together to solve those problems. While reading this work, the idea of Watery Motivation struck me the most.


Watery Motivation comes up when Nussbaum reminds us of Aristotle's criticism of Plato's Republic which read "there are two things above all that make people love and care for something, the thought that is is all theirs, and the thought that it is the only one they have. Neither of these will be present in [The Republic]". Nor do they seem to be present in international space development.


It seems to get worse for international activity as Nussbuam disproves the idea that we can dissolve the attachments to the local world to allow for international cooperation. But, she goes on to claim that "a patriotism constrained by respect for human dignity and by a vivid sense of the real losses and needs of others" will allow for international response to the world's challenges. I believe this same reason will allow for peace during the land rush that we will see at the dawn of the next space age.


So yes, we will get Base Eagle and Base Freedom and we will get to chant "USA!" in the world of international space development. But, out of respect for the needs of others, we won't hog the Moon and Mars for ourselves. Our acknowledgment of human dignity will prevent us from causing suffering with our activities in space. Thus, no matter how political our activity in space is, we can still work with others. It all comes down to whether or not we constrain our patriotism.


~In Case You Skimmed


-Respect for others will allow for highly political national space programs to coexist with international space goals


~Reactions


-Is this dangerous, does allow for patriotism to exist in space bring us to close to shattering the dream of a peaceful space age.


~Resources


Nussbaum, Martha C. “Compassion and Terror.” Daedalus. 132 (Winter 2003): 10-26.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

CAT: Political Cycles

Welcome to Counter Argument Thursday (CAT). This is where I write blog post the is opposite and critical of my position on space habitation and space habitation. I do not agree with the position in the blog post, but it is an argument I need to address.

Space habitation is a dream that cannot survival the vicious political cycles in modern government structures, just like every plan that takes multiple generations. space habitation will take at least two generations. Even a moon base takes 30 years to build, as claimed in the paper Lunar Industries and Their Value for the Human Environment on Earth. I can’t even claim there will be long term political stability in a totalitarian state, they too have political cycles.  In fact, unless a long term goal in woven into the social fabric of a nation, it won’t get done. Furthermore, to be blunt, space is far from being woven into the social fabric of, at least, the United States. I offer the Rasmussen Reports article 50% Favor Cutting Back on Space Exploration as proof. If a moon landing can’t make space into a social goal, nothing can. Thus, there will be progress toward space habitation while it is politically favorable and that progress will be halted when the tides turn.

In Case You Skimmed

-Space habitation is a long term goal the requires political stability.

-Political stability simply doesn’t exist

Reactions

-Could an international organization offer the political stability needed to space habitation?

-Could space habitation research hibernate in academia during politically rough times, only to reemerge better then ever when the public is ready?

-Will there be funding for space habitation in academia during politically rough times?

-Will there be a student interest in space habitation during politically rough times?

Resources

Krafft A. Ehricke, Lunar industries and their value for the human environment on Earth, Acta Astronautica, Volume 1, Issues 5-6, May-June 1974, Pages 585-622, ISSN 0094-5765, DOI: 10.1016/0094-5765(74)90023-X. (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/B6V1N-4805SJ8-5/2/4d9bdc1efb4a1a033b97f934b0fe09e8)

Rasmussen Reports, “50% Favor Cutting Back on Space Exploration” Weblog entry. Rasmussen Reports. January 15, 2010. January 18, 2010 <http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/lifestyle/general_lifestyle/

january_2010/50_favor_cutting_back_on_space_exploration>




Related Posts with Thumbnails